The Performance Marketing Trap: How to Pivot to Brand (Without the Massive Budget)

If your LinkedIn or podcast feeds looks anything like mine, you’ve probably noticed brand being framed as “the next big thing” in marketing. But that raises a more important question: why did brand fall out of favour in the first place — and what’s changed to bring it back?

Brand’s comeback

WARC’s recent report, The Multiplier Effect, has helped reignite the conversation. Its conclusion is clear: the most effective companies don’t choose between brand and performance — they invest in both, and benefit from the compounding effects.

But this idea isn’t new.

Byron Sharp and the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute made the case in How Brands Grow. Binet and Field reinforced it in The Long and the Short of It. For over a decade, marketing science has consistently shown that long-term growth comes from balancing demand creation with demand capture.

So why was this message so easy to ignore?

Part of the answer is practical. Many of the companies featured in these studies had access to category data, large budgets, and years of pre-digital marketing experience. Most marketers didn’t. For those working with smaller budgets and increasing pressure to prove ROI, performance marketing — supported by MarTech and attribution — promised clarity, control and immediate results. Unsurprisingly, it won.

The result was a generation of marketers optimising brilliantly for the short term, while struggling to sustain growth over time.

So if you, like many, went deep down the performance marketing rabbit hole, the question now is: how do you climb back out and rebuild brand in a way that feels credible, measurable and commercially responsible?

What the Marketing Science says

In simple terms, growth stalls when performance marketing runs out of people to convert.

Performance marketing is very good at harvesting demand that already exists. It targets people who are ready to buy now — typically around 5% of the market at any given time. Once those people have converted, performance campaigns hit a ceiling. You can’t squeeze much more growth out of consumers who simply don’t need or want to buy more – and so growth plateaus.

The missing piece is the other 95% of people — those who are not shopping right now, but will be in the future. Performance marketing largely ignores them because they don’t convert immediately.

Brand awareness campaigns solve this problem by efficiently reaching future customers, building familiarity, and making your brand feel like a safe, obvious choice. So when people eventually enter the category, you’re already in their consideration set.

In short:

  • Performance marketing converts demand that already exists

  • Brand marketing creates demand for the future, and

  • You need both to keep growing

 

It’s an important and logical point, but for marketers not spending at saturation levels, it’s a hard one to see when looking at their own data. So why are we seeing such a swing back to brand?

Everything was measurable, until it wasn’t

Regulation and platform changes have steadily eroded the tracking marketers once relied on. GDPR in 2018 limited how data could be collected. Apple’s iOS 14.5 update in 2021 restricted user-level tracking even further. Together, they punched holes in the attribution “proof” that made performance marketing feel precise and dependable.

At the same time, attribution itself has become harder to trust. In 2023, Google removed familiar models like linear attribution and pushed marketers toward Data-Driven Attribution — a black-box system that asks us to trust the same platforms we buy media from to fairly credit themselves. Last-touch attribution hasn’t helped either, because it over-rewards the final click while ignoring all the activity that created demand earlier.

The result is confusion, not clarity. Each platform reports its own version of performance, often claiming the same conversion. Channel reports inflate results because pixels compete for credit, making it almost impossible to establish a true “single source of truth.”

Finance teams see the problem clearly. When CFOs compare these reports to real sales and revenue, the numbers don’t line up. That gap is putting pressure on marketers, who are being asked to defend results built on fragile attribution models.

Seeing the forest for the trees

As traditional attribution has weakened, Marketing Mix Models (MMMs) are stepping in to fill the gap.

MMMs work differently to pixel-based attribution. Instead of tracking individual users, they look at patterns over time. Using a simple signal-and-response approach, they analyse historical data to understand how changes in marketing activity (the signal) relate to changes in business outcomes like sales or revenue (the response). This allows marketers to estimate which channels are genuinely driving incremental impact.

Because MMMs take a more zoomed-out view, they often reveal insights that performance reporting misses.

For example, our own analysis shows that marketing today operates in an attention economy. We’ve seen strong correlations between high-engagement activity — such as polls and video campaigns on Meta — and revenue outcomes. In many cases, optimising for video views or engagement outperforms optimising purely for reach.

This matters because it challenges a long-held assumption. Performance marketing taught us to dismiss engagement indicators as “vanity metrics.” But when viewed through an MMM lens, these signals appear to contribute to mental availability — making brands easier to notice, remember and choose later. In other words, engagement isn’t just noise; it can be an early indicator of future demand.

The catch is that traditional MMMs are often hard to access. They’re expensive, usually require several years of clean data, and rely on complex statistical modelling that many marketers can’t explain.

That’s why, for teams who want to start exploring MMM thinking without the high cost or complexity, Paper + Spark has developed a more accessible way to dip your toe in.

Share of search: your secret weapon

Share of Search is a simple but powerful indicator of brand strength.

Marketing science shows that a brand’s share of search — how often people search for your brand compared to competitors — tends to move in line with market share over time. In practice, this means that brands people search for more, sell more.

You can calculate share of search by taking the branded search volume for every major brand in your category and comparing them against each other. No pixels or attribution models required.

For CMOs trying to justify brand investment, this is especially useful. Tracking share of search over time creates a clear narrative: as brand activity increases, search interest grows — and sales often follow in the medium to long term.

In categories like FMCG, this effect is often easier to prove because category-level sales data is available. By comparing branded search volumes with sales data across brands, you can calculate correlations that help show how growing mental availability translates into revenue. When it doesn’t, it’s often a signal to look beyond marketing — with physical availability (distribution, price, or ease of purchase) a common limiting factor.

Demist Consulting, Redacted Category Analysis, 2025

Not every industry has access to shared sales data or clean market share benchmarks. But that doesn’t mean you’re stuck.

Searching for clues

Here’s the good news: you probably already have access to basic data that can help build your business case for Brand without category data or expensive modelling.

Two key traffic sources tell an interesting story:

  • Branded search traffic: This is traffic that arrives via searches for your brand name (or close variations). It’s a strong signal that people already know you and are actively seeking you out.
  • Direct traffic: These are visitors who type your URL directly into their browser or use a saved bookmark. This behaviour reflects brand awareness, familiarity, and intent.

From a performance perspective, these users matter because they consistently convert at the highest rates. They arrive primed, confident, and closer to purchase. So optimising for these traffic sources makes commercial sense.

Here’s the key insight: You can’t meaningfully grow branded search or direct traffic through performance tactics. To grow these high-converting traffic sources, you need to invest in brand activity that builds awareness, familiarity, and memory over time.

One important caveat: as these signals grow, keep an eye on new vs returning users. You want to be confident that you’re expanding the pool of future customers — not just repeatedly converting the same ones.

In short, even without category data, your own traffic patterns can tell a compelling brand story — if you know where to look.

Brand baby steps

You don’t need to overhaul your media mix to start building brand.

Channels already sitting in most performance plans — like Google and Meta — can be used as low-cost entry points into brand building. With CPMs often around $7 and the ability to reach 80–90% of a target audience, these platforms offer strong value. Crucially, they also allow brands to stay consistently in market, which marketing science shows is far more effective than short, stop-start bursts.

How to use them effectively

From our experience, optimising for light engagement (such as video views, reactions, or simple interactions) tends to outperform optimising for reach alone.

But just as important as the objective is how you use targeting.

As privacy restrictions increase, traditional interest-based and demographic targeting have become less reliable. Instead of trying to outsmart the platforms with ever-narrower targeting, the most effective approach is to shift the focus to creative.

In practice, that means:

  • Treating creative as the main variable, not targeting

  • Structuring campaigns around clear content pillars

  • Allowing audiences to form based on how people engage with that content

When you do this, you’re letting the platform’s algorithm do what it’s designed to do: find more people who behave like those already engaging with your brand.

Google and Meta are inexpensive, flexible, fast, and probably already part of your performance mix. They’re also a great test bed for creative and messaging, making them a great stepping-stone before committing to higher-investment channels such as TV or OOH.

AI as an opportunity for Brand

AI already has the attention of boardrooms. The mistake many teams make is treating AI as a technology conversation, when in reality it’s increasingly a brand conversation. How your brand shows up in AI-generated answers is determined by the signals you’ve built over time.

Some argue that AI will diminish the role of brands, that future decisions will rely purely on product attributes, with AI tools scanning reviews and content to recommend the “best” option. But this view misses a critical point: AI doesn’t invent opinions; it reflects the information available to it.

If you want AI to recommend your brand, you need to influence the content it draws from.

It helps to think of tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Claude as the next generation of search engines. Each draws from different sources:

  • Gemini relies heavily on Google Search and Google Reviews

  • ChatGPT leans on Bing-indexed content, forums and online discussions

  • Perplexity pulls more strongly from academic and publisher content

What unites them is this: they surface the most visible, credible and widely referenced signals.

That’s where brand comes in.

Brand activity shapes the signals AI sees.

Early adopters, influencers, publishers and customers generate the reviews, discussions, ratings and thought leadership that AI systems later summarise and recommend. Brands that are talked about, reviewed and referenced are far more likely to be surfaced than brands that are invisible.

At the same time, the line between brand and product is narrowing. Increasingly, your product experience is your brand. If customers don’t have a good experience, the signals AI relies on — reviews, sentiment, recommendations — simply won’t exist.

So building brand in an AI-led world means:

  • Investing in user experiences that earn strong Net Promoter Scores

  • Actively encouraging user-generated content like reviews and customer stories

  • Ensuring your brand is consistently present in the places AI learns from, like earned media

AI won’t replace brand. But it will increasingly reward the brands that have done the work to be visible, credible and worth recommending.

Build brand inertia, not just awareness

If AI surfaces what’s already visible and trusted, then success in AI search isn’t just about being known, it’s about being credible.

To show up in AI-generated recommendations, brands need more than awareness. They need groundswell: signals of trust, relevance and momentum that accumulate over time. This is where brand investment compounds.

The next step beyond always-on digital brand activity is to invest in channels that create credibility at scale:

  • Public relations: Earned coverage in established publications borrows trust and authority, while also delivering reach. These references become part of the public record AI tools draw from.
  • Podcast voice reads: Endorsements from trusted industry voices reach highly engaged audiences, particularly early adopters. The credibility transfer is powerful because it feels personal, not promotional.
  • Influencer partnerships: Carefully chosen creators add authenticity and social proof with key segments. When done well, this content fuels conversation, sharing and secondary coverage.

Why this works

Together, these channels generate the social proof and credibility that create brand inertia — the momentum a brand builds when awareness turns into recommendation, sharing and repeat exposure.

Once established, brand inertia is easier to maintain than to create. It requires less spend to sustain and delivers a durable competitive advantage, provided the customer experience lives up to the promise. In that sense, brand building becomes the gift that keeps on giving.

This also explains why brand works so early in the journey. By building preference long before someone is ready to buy, you enter the consideration set ahead of time. When the moment of choice arrives, confirmation bias does the rest.

After all, how often have you trawled reviews — or asked an AI tool for advice — not to decide what to buy, but to justify a decision you’d already made?

Finding harmony

The most effective marketers aren’t choosing between brand and performance. They’re orchestrating both — building future demand while efficiently converting today’s customers.

What we’re seeing now isn’t a rejection of performance marketing, but a rebalancing as its shortcomings become more obvious. Brand is coming back into focus because the limits of optimisation-led growth are clearer, and because the signals that matter — attention, credibility, and memory — can’t be fully captured by short-term attribution.

The path forward doesn’t require perfect measurement. It requires good judgement. Use the data clues you already have to test ideas, learn what works, and build confidence in the direction of travel. Resist the temptation to optimise every decision to the algorithm, and don’t let the absence of perfect proof stall progress.

When brand and performance work together — informed by evidence, not constrained by it — marketing becomes more effective, more sustainable, and frankly, more rewarding..

Ready to turn campaigns and creative into engines of long-term growth? Email Ben@paperandspark.com.au to discuss how we can apply marketing science, technology and creativity to your business.

GOT A PROJECT IN MIND?

Facebook
LinkedIn
Email